A rather odd on line fight has broken out between those who hate the movie Love Actually, and those who defend it. (The 10 year anniversary of its release seems to be the motivation for this re-assessment.)
Christopher Orr started it with his lengthy explanation of why he thinks the movie is awful and actually anti-romantic. His critique is not perfect - he says he thinks Bill Nighy is terrific, whereas I always find him hammy and annoying. But he makes a pretty strong case against the movie overall.
(I just found the movie extremely unconvincing in virtually every story thread. I wrote at the time that I found some of the stories verging on creepy, but I've actually forgotten which ones now.)
Orr's article has now been followed by this:
I Will Not Be Ashamed of Loving Love Actually - Emma Green - The Atlantic
and she brings in CS Lewis to defend her take on the movie. (!) [I somehow have my doubts that he would have taken to the love story between actors doing fake porn scenes.]
Other haters and lover of the movie have taken this as a cue to join in. I see that this Australian entry is pretty good - she seems to dislike it in pretty much exactly the same ways I do. After than, you can read a defence of the movie on Mother Earth News. Then you can go visit another Australian woman who dislikes the movie.
I think the "noes" have it.
UPDATE: An English young bloke in The Guardian now has a go at Australians for criticising it, even though this round of criticism started in America, declaring it his favourite movie, ever. (!) I think he should be a little embarrassed about that, in all honesty.
No comments:
Post a Comment